Panel builders, installers, engineering department,…Before the multiplication of energy efficiency solutions to install in the small buildings
and commercial buildings, you are facing many difficulties to choose
the best technology for the energy collection; the one which will
address the needs of your customers, while being easy to use and to
install.
The lack of information, knowledge and means makes you take a risk and also lose valuable time.
Installing an inappropriate device, partially replying to the technical requirements specifications, calling on a local collaborator whom reliability and reputation remain uncertain, taking a specific programme causing additional cost, is a significant risk factors and does not guarantee the working of your installation.
A lot of panel builders – maybe like you? – do not even respond to a call to tender involving energy efficiency solutions! Yet, theses are increasing demands and you won’t be able to develop your company without incorporating these solutions in and earning this expertise.
Facing this issue, we decided to go into action to test solutions for energy data logger for small buildings and commercial buildings. Here is how we made these tests:
We dissociated two aspects:
We’ve rather compared solutions intended for panel buildings and products from manufacturers who propose offers available in the greatest number of countries.
Check the rating of the solutions below:
What do you think about our comparison? Feel free to give your opinion on these solutions and let’s exchange about the other options you have in your countries.
The lack of information, knowledge and means makes you take a risk and also lose valuable time.
Installing an inappropriate device, partially replying to the technical requirements specifications, calling on a local collaborator whom reliability and reputation remain uncertain, taking a specific programme causing additional cost, is a significant risk factors and does not guarantee the working of your installation.
A lot of panel builders – maybe like you? – do not even respond to a call to tender involving energy efficiency solutions! Yet, theses are increasing demands and you won’t be able to develop your company without incorporating these solutions in and earning this expertise.
Facing this issue, we decided to go into action to test solutions for energy data logger for small buildings and commercial buildings. Here is how we made these tests:
We dissociated two aspects:
- The connectivity of the data logger and the interfacing possibilities
- The configuration of the software (i.e user-friendliness and features)
We’ve rather compared solutions intended for panel buildings and products from manufacturers who propose offers available in the greatest number of countries.
Check the rating of the solutions below:
| Manufacturer Product | HMS | Schneider Electric Com’X 200 | Eaton PXG600 | eWon 4005CD |
| Image + Link |  |
 |
 |
 |
| View Manufacturer Product |  |
|
|
|
| Hardware | ||||
| Power supply | 24Vdc | 100-230Vac, 24Vdc, POE | 24Vdc | 24Vdc |
| Communication | Ethernet (GPRS different part number) | Ethernet, GPRS and Wi-Fi | Ethernet | Ethernet+ GPRS |
| I/Os | 2DI: status, pulse 1 DO |
6DI :Status, pulse 2AI: 0-10V, 4-20mA, PT100, PT1000 24Vdc for sensor power supply |
– | 1DI/1DO |
| Ports | 1 Ethernet port 1 RS485 port, 1 RS232 port |
2 Ethernet ports (separated or switched) 1 RS485 port |
2 Ethernet ports (separated) 3 serial ports |
4 Ethernet ports (switch) 1 serial port RS485/RS232 |
| Software | ||||
| Easiness to configure | Through webpages Device model uploaded from website but not up to date |
Through webpages Automatic discovery of devices Library of pre-configured devices Wi-Fi access to connect with a laptop or tablet |
Through webpages Automatic discovery of devices Library of pre-configured devices |
Through webpages |
| Custom device type management | Device model creation Import/export |
Device model creation Import/export |
Device model creation Import/export |
– |
| Export format / transfer protocol | Proprieritary format, CSV file only for download on local computer SMTP |
XML, CSV file FTP, HTTP, HTTPS, SMTP Proxy management |
CSV file | CSV file FTP, e-mail transfer |
| Data acquisition protocols | Modbus-RTU, ASCII, TCP/IP | Modbus TCP/ RTU | Modbus TCP/ RTU | Unitelway, PROFIBUS, FINS Hostlink, FINS TCP, EtherNet/IP™, ISO TCP |
| Event logs | no | yes | yes | yes |
| Save/restore configuration | yes | yes | yes | yes |
| Remote access / management | Remote access, FW upgrade and troubleshooting | For technical support, FW upgrade and troubleshooting | – | Remote access, FW upgrade and troubleshooting |
| Alarming | yes | no | yes | yes |
| Control / Programming | no | no | no | yes |
| User management | yes- several levels | no | yes- 2 levels | yes- several levels |
| Synthesis | ||||
+ |
Easy to configure Small size |
Easy to configure Wide connectivity Wi-Fi access for configuration |
Really adapted to monitor electrical distribution Webpages for trend viewing |
Highly customizable Wide range of protocols |
– |
Proprietary format, only work with netbiter Argos server Not enough I/Os |
No alarming Only 1 serial port |
Size is big and mounting DIN kit is not very adapted to electrical panelboard No I/Os No GPRS IHM looks old |
Difficult to configure, a lot of parameters to enter, requires to know PLC programming Not enough I/Os |
| View Manufacturer Product | |
|
|
|
What do you think about our comparison? Feel free to give your opinion on these solutions and let’s exchange about the other options you have in your countries.
No comments:
Post a Comment